Defenders Compensates For Boulder Livestock Losses

(10/12/1995) - Defenders of Wildlife today announced it has compensated two Boulder, Montana, ranchers for four calves that were killed by wolves. These are wolves that have naturally migrated on their own from Canada into the United States and are not part of the wolf reintroduction program that restored wolves into Yellowstone National Park and central Idaho in January 1995.

Three of the losses occurred this September, and one occurred in the summer of 1994. The ranchers received $1,633 for the stock, their own estimate of the calves' value.

Hank Fischer, Defenders' Northern Rockies Representative, stated the following in a letter accompanying the compensation payment:

Although, Defenders of Wildlife feels strongly that wolves should return to Montana, it's not our intent for this recovery to occur at the expense of livestock producers. We remain convinced that wolves and humans can co-exist in Montana, as they do in Minnesota and many parts of Canada. But it will require both tolerance on the part of livestock producers and understanding on the part of the public that depredation can be economically significant to individual ranchers.

The payment to one of the ranchers included compensation for a calf that was lost in 1994. Although it is unorthodox for Defenders to compensate now for a livestock loss that occurred a year earlier, the livestock producer provided photos and information that allowed animal damage control expert Carter Niemeyer to verify the loss.

Fischer said, "Defenders believes it has gone the extra mile to make its Wolf Compensation Fund fair to livestock producers. Several ranchers told us that paying market value for young calves didn't reflect the significant investment that producers have in their calf crop. Consequently, we changed our compensation policy and now pay fall value for calves killed at any time of the year."

Fischer points out that in the occasional situation where a loss cannot be verified, yet substantial circumstantial evidence of wolf predation exists, Defenders has compensated the ranchers at 50% of market value.

Defenders' Wolf Compensation Fund was attacked last week in Montana and Wyoming newspapers by the Wyoming Farm Bureau Federation because Defenders refused to pay for a calf that died near Salmon, Idaho. A U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service forensics lab autopsy concluded that the calf had died of natural causes shortly after birth.

Fischer stated, "While we refuse to pay for claims that cannot be verified, we stand firmly behind our commitment to pay for all legitimate claims. Because the Farm Bureau is an insurance agency, it should understand better than anyone that the success and credibility of Defenders' Wolf Compensation Fund depends on making payments only to people who deserve them. Does the Farm Bureau's insurance business pay for unverified losses? Would the Farm Bureau make a payment if its adjusters determined no loss had occurred? We don't think so. It's frustrating for us to offer a helping hand and have it slapped away. Fortunately, many ranchers and most mainstream livestock organizations have expressed heartfelt appreciation for our voluntary program."

Defenders of Wildlife has operated its Wolf Compensation Fund in Montana since 1987. During that time, it has paid approximately $20,000 to more than twenty ranchers. The program was expanded in 1994 to cover any livestock losses caused by the recently reintroduced wolf populations in the Yellowstone and central Idaho. Defenders has also pledged to pay for any livestock losses caused by wolves in Arizona and New Mexico, where reintroductions are being contemplated.



Cat Lazaroff, (202) 772-3270

You may also be interested in:

Defenders in Action
Bears die when they get into trouble with people’s garbage, livestock, when they are hit by cars and trains or illegally killed. By preventing these conflicts we can keep bears alive and on the road to recovery.
Fact Sheet
Prairie dogs are burrowing rodents that live in large colonies in the grasslands of central and western North America.
Gray Wolf, © Dawn Hammond
Fact Sheet
The wolf is the largest member of the canine family. Gray wolves range in color from grizzled gray or black to all-white. As the ancestor of the domestic dog, the gray wolf resembles German shepherds or malamutes.