Administration Issues proposed "No Surprises" Rule On Endangered Species Act

(05/29/1997) - The Clinton Administration today issued a proposed rule to codify its controversial `No Surprises' policy under the Endangered Species Act (ESA). The `No Surprises' policy has been denounced by environmental groups and scientists as being inconsistent with the ESA and the conservation of endangered and threatened species. The policy locks-in often unproven mitigation measures in Habitat Conservation Plans (HCP's). HCP's are developed in return for permits that authorize the "incidental take" of endangered and threatened species. These plans can cover hundreds of species, they may apply to hundreds of thousands of acres, and they may last more than 100 years. After an HCP is approved and an Incidental Take Permit is issued, the `No Surprises' policy precludes the federal government from requiring certain additional conservation measures from the permit holder, even if the HCP is failing and species are declining as a result.

"We believe strongly that the `No Surprises' policy, as currently implemented, is scientifically indefensible and contrary to the goals and purposes of the Endangered Species Act. It should be repealed," said Defenders of Wildlife President Rodger Schlickeisen.

In July of 1996 more than 160 scientists signed a letter addressed to Senator John Chafee and Congressman James Saxton criticizing `No Surprises' as proposed in legislation to reauthorize the ESA. The scientists wrote, "...this [No Surprises] section does not reflect ecological reality and rejects the best scientific knowledge and judgment of our era. It proposes a world that does not, has not, and will never exist."

The proposed rule was issued in response to a settlement agreement reached between the federal government and environmental groups opposed to the policy. Public comments will be solicited on the proposed rule until July 28, 1997, after which time the federal government will decide whether to amend, repeal, or reissue the policy as currently implemented.

"We hope the Clinton Administration in good faith will weigh the public's concerns with `No Surprises' and take the opportunity provided by the comment period to reconsider the wisdom of this policy," said Schlickeisen.



Cat Lazaroff, (202) 772-3270

You may also be interested in:

Fact Sheet
Cactus ferruginous pygmy-owls are one of three subspecies of the ferruginous pygmy-owl. They have longer tails than most owls, are reddish-brown with a cream colored belly and have a crown that is lightly streaked.
Fact Sheet
Right whales like the North Atlantic right whale are among the rarest of all marine mammal species. These baleen whales have two separate populations – western and eastern.
Sea Turtle, © Christina Albright-Mundy
Fact Sheet
Sea turtles are one of the Earth's most ancient creatures. The seven species that can be found today have been around for 110 million years, since the time of the dinosaurs.