Defenders Magazine

Spring 2003

Defenders in Action: Commerce Department Weakens 'Dolphin-Safe' Labels

Defenders of Wildlife is challenging a Bush administration decision that would result in the deaths of thousands more Pacific dolphins.

The Commerce Department weakened the requirements for using "dolphin-safe" labels on cans of tuna fish sold in the United States. The ruling would permit companies in Mexico and Ecuador to ship tuna to the United States even if fishermen caught the tuna by purposely encircling dolphins in their nets. Thousands of dolphins are killed every year by Pacific tuna fishing fleets when they encircle dolphins to catch the tuna swimming underneath.

"We have great confidence that the courts will strike down this blatantly illegal decision," says William Snape, Defenders of Wildlife vice president and chief counsel.

The Commerce Department acted despite a long-awaited scientific study by the National Marine Fisheries Service that contradicts claims by U.S. and Mexican officials that fishing practices have improved. The study, which only became public after it was leaked to the news media, found depleted populations of dolphins are not recovering in the Pacific.

As they are chased by tuna fishing fleets and their helicopters, untold thousands of dolphins die from stress, severe injury and separation of calves and mothers, according to the study by U.S. government scientists.