Green Scene: The Vaquita's Vanishing Act

The pair of stubby-nose porpoises surfaces as though parting a glossy veil. The vaquitas take a quick gulp of air, and then just as suddenly as they appeared, they sink back into the Sea of Cortez’s murky waters.

By James Navarro

Vaquita, © Chris Johnson/Earthocean/

© Chris Johnson/Earthocean/
Everything about them—from the mask-like rings around their eyes to the dark gray color of their bodies—underscores their shy, elusive nature. Perhaps that’s why the world’s smallest porpoise has been slipping closer to extinction right before our eyes.

Scientists fear that the five-foot-long vaquitas, which were indentified just over a half-century ago in the waters between the Baja peninsula and the Mexican mainland, won’t last another 20 years. Lorenzo Rojas Bracho, a marine biologist with Mexico’s National Institute of Ecology, is part of a team of scientists who have been studying vaquitas for the past decade—counting their numbers from boats and listening to their calls, or clicks, using undersea microphones. But for Rojas the past 10 years may have seemed more like a long vigil than a census, as vaquita numbers have steadily withered away to just 250 animals—down from some 600 in the mid-1990s.

“Fishing is the main threat to the vaquita’s survival,” Rojas says. “It’s a species that’s going extinct because of human interference.”

Most of these “little cows”—the English translation of “vaquitas”—have been claimed by commercial fishing. The porpoises get tangled and drown in nets beside captured sea bass, mackerel and shrimp, which are prized by seafood markets and restaurants in Mexico, the United States and abroad. But unlike cattle, these endangered porpoises are worthless to fishermen, who toss the dead bodies thoughtlessly out to sea.

“The only way to save the vaquita is to stop fishing where it lives,” says Juan Carlos Cantu Guzman, director of Defenders of Wildlife’s Mexico office. A biologist by training, Cantu is lobbying Mexican authorities to strengthen protections inside the 500-square-mile vaquita refuge area.

Established in 2005 by the Mexican government, the marine reserve offers little security for the porpoises. “It is a refuge in name only,” Cantu says. “The government just last year declined authorization for shrimp trawlers to fish inside the refuge, and gillnetting is still happening nearby, where vaquitas also live.”

Stay Informed
Learn more about this endangered porpoise.

Until recently, the shrimping season—from September to March—lured hundreds of fishing boats to the preserve and its surrounding waters. “The situation got so bad that nobody knows how many boats or gillnets were out there,” Rojas says.

Fortunately, the efforts of Cantu and other conservationists are starting to turn the tide. In 2007, the Mexican government began buying out local fishermen, encouraging them to lay down their nets and use their boats for ecotourism instead. Change, however, comes slowly here, says Cantu, noting that the early program was plagued by fraud. Some fishermen used the cash from trading in their permits to renovate their boats and to buy more effective and deadly gear.

Today the program can claim some success, however, with the removal of nearly 230 fishing vessels from the vaquita’s waters. Rojas credits a new requirement that fishermen submit detailed business plans proving how their buy-out money will be spent. Still some 400 to 500 fishermen are holding out, he says, because fishing here isn’t just a job—it’s a tradition handed down for generations. But the global economic downturn, falling seafood prices and overharvested fisheries may soon chase even the most devout fishermen off the seas.

“It’s getting tougher to make a good living from catching fish,” Rojas says. “Many have told us they don’t want their kids to be fishermen.”

Meanwhile, vaquitas are still dying at an alarming rate and conservation groups are calling for a government moratorium on fishing in the vaquita’s sole habitat. “If gillnetting doesn’t stop soon,” says Cantu, “vaquitas may eventually pay the highest price of all.”

More Articles from Summer 2010

Defenders of Wildlife’s 2010 photo contest winners. The grand-prize photo won a tour to Yellowstone and Grand Teton national parks with expert wildlife photographer Jess Lee.
Maligned as killing machines, sharks are an essential part of healthy oceans. Millions of sharks are killed every year to fill soup bowls.
These furry engineers play a crucial and largely unrecognized roles in conservation - Eager for Beavers
If you were driving a car toward a cliff, would you step on the gas pedal or hit the brakes? Would you try to stop the car or keep driving, thinking that any injury you sustained would be patched up in the hospital later?
Wildlife features in Defenders Summer 2010 Magazine: Have Fur, Will Travel; Global Warming National Park?; The High Price Isn’t Always at the Pump; Bycatch Be Gone; Sweet Flowers Lure Ladies
For sea turtles, fish, shorebirds, seabirds, corals, dolphins, whales and other wildlife that live part or all of their lives in the Gulf of Mexico, the unprecedented oil leak is catastrophic.
While the desert may look deserted to some, the land where these companies want to site their projects is often home to species such as the threatened desert tortoise that don’t have other places to go.
A group advising the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service agreed on draft wind energy siting recommendations detailing how to avoid sensitive wildlife habitat and decrease the chances of birds and bats being killed by wind turbines.
Wrong Turn for Right Whales, Fishers Gets Traction, Giving Back on Earth Day
This is the heart of wolf country in the West, a place where Defenders of Wildlife is helping ranchers keep both their flocks and resident wolves safe.
Although the supermarket’s canned food aisle may be the closest many Americans have come to a school of tuna, the species is among the oceans’ most fascinating fish.
“It was a dark day for polar bears,” says Defenders’ Peter Jenkins, director of international conservation.